860 Payne Ave, St. Paul, MN 55130 Mon to Fri 9am to 6pm 651-493-9484
A black classic Monte Carlo on gold wheels inside the O'Keeffe's Collision shop
Family owned · St. Paul, MN

Collision repair & paint on Payne Avenue.

A family owned body shop on Payne Avenue. Collision repair, hail damage and paint matching, with free estimates and every insurance company welcome.

  • Free estimates
  • All insurance companies
  • 30+ years experience
Free estimatesIn person, by email or on your phone
Every insurerWe work with all insurance companies
Free loaner carsWith qualifying insurance repairs
4.6 on GoogleFrom 76 customer reviews
What we fix

Dents, dings and the big ones

From a parking lot scrape to a crash that needs the frame pulled straight, we handle it in house and send it home looking right.

Collision repair

Body work after an accident, big or small. Our on-site frame rack gets your car back to factory straight.

Hail & dent repair

Storm damage and door dings fixed, including paintless dent removal that keeps your factory paint.

Paint & custom paint

Paint matched so close you can't tell where the repair is. Custom work too, from collector cars to bikes.

Bumpers

Cracked, scuffed or hanging off. We repair or replace bumpers and match the color.

Glass & mirrors

Windshield replacement and side mirror replacement, done right here at the shop.

Detailing

A full line of detailing services, plus car and truck accessories.

Our work

Before & after

Real cars repaired at our shop on Payne Avenue. Tap any photo to see it bigger.

Ram pickup before repair, with a crushed bed side, bent rear bumper and cracked taillightBefore
The same Ram pickup after repair, bed side, bumper and taillight like newAfter
Ram pickupBed side, rear bumper and taillight
White Chevy Impala before repair, with the front bumper, headlight and fender torn awayBefore
The same Chevy Impala after repair with a new front endAfter
Chevy ImpalaFront end, fender and headlight
Silver Cadillac Escalade before repair, with a dented fender, scraped bumper and cracked lightsBefore
The same Cadillac Escalade after repair in the shopAfter
Cadillac EscaladeFender, bumper and lights
Black Lincoln Navigator before repair, with a missing headlight and broken grilleBefore
The same Lincoln Navigator after repair with a new grille and headlightsAfter
Lincoln NavigatorGrille, headlight and bumper
Silver Nissan Altima before repair, with a deep dent in the rear doorBefore
The same Nissan Altima after repair with a straight rear doorAfter
Nissan AltimaRear door dent
Gray Pontiac Grand Prix before repair, with a caved-in front bumper cornerBefore
The same Pontiac Grand Prix after repair with a smooth front bumperAfter
Pontiac Grand PrixFront bumper
The black and red O'Keeffe's Collision metal sign in the front office
Insurance claims

We handle the insurance headache

We work with all insurance companies and walk you through the claim. You don't have to fight it alone.

  1. Call or stop inBring the car by Payne Ave, or email us photos for a quick look.
  2. Free estimateWe write it up at no cost, in person, by email or on your phone.
  3. We work with your insurerWe help with the claim so the repair gets approved and paid.
  4. Back on the roadFree loaner cars with qualifying insurance repairs, by appointment.
Start my free estimate
Our shop

On Payne Avenue

Look for the red brick building with the striped awning in the Payne-Phalen neighborhood.

The O'Keeffe's Collision storefront at 860 Payne Ave in St. Paul
Family owned

A neighborhood shop that treats your car like theirs

O'Keeffe's Collision is a family owned and operated body shop in St. Paul's historic Payne-Phalen neighborhood. Owner Dave O'Keeffe and his crew bring 30+ years in collision repair and paint to every car that rolls in.

30+Years in collision & paint
4.6Stars on Google
$0For an estimate
Reviews

Don't take our word for it

4.676 Google reviews
"I searched high and low looking for any evidence of having repairs done, and found none. The paint matched perfectly."
Bryan B.Google review
"They did fantastic work on my new Enclave after some nasty hail, at a price that was beyond fair. Im an insurance agent and this one of the few shops I will recommend."
William A.Google review
"These people did the best job I have EVER SEEN. Amazing timing, great customer service, & flawless job."
Kayla H.Google review
"Dave and his crew are very friendly and professional! They do excellent work and I would highly recommend them!!"
Krysta B.Facebook review
"They do great work and Dan is fair and honest. Highly recommend!"
Christina F.Google review
"We also trusted Dave to paint our collector Chevy Impala and most recently, our Harley."
Faith G.Yelp review
Visit or get an estimate

Stop by or send us photos

Estimates are always free. Swing by during business hours, call us, or fill out the form and we'll get back to you.

O'Keeffe's Collision

Request a free estimate

Tell us about the car and what happened. We'll reach out to set up a time.

Have photos of the damage? Email them to [email protected] for a faster estimate.

Thanks, we got it

Your request is on its way to the shop. We'll reach out to set up a time. Need us sooner? Call 651-493-9484.

Almost done

Your email app should open with your request filled in. Just hit send. Or call us at 651-493-9484.

Call now Free estimate